Partisanship and School Committee: Our Work is Partisan

iBerkshires.com released its candidate profile for all of the candidates running for Pittsfield School Committee, go check it out here.

One of the questions they asked was “What political party are you affiliated with?” The candidates responded as follows:

Batory: “Independent, but I don’t believe political affiliation should play a role in public education. School Committee members are elected to serve all students, families, and staff — regardless of political party. My focus is on transparency, accountability, and making decisions that benefit our children, not partisan interests.”

Muil: “Democrat”

Elias: “Registered independent.”

Yon: “N/A”

Klein: “Unenrolled.”

Beurger: “None.”

McNeice: “I am registered as Independent, but most often lean toward the Democratic party”

Smith: “This is a nonpartisan position.”

Barry: No response to iBerkshires.

While the School Committee, and all elected offices in the City of Pittsfield, are in fact non-partisan, that does not mean our work is non-partisan.

The job of the School Committee is to serve our students, to support them and protect them. While we may disagree on how this School Committee has done that, I think we can all agree that this is the purpose of the Committee. Unfortunately, in this day and age, protecting students and even people now falls into partisan categories.

When you have a federal government who is attacking public education, defunding offices in the Department of Education meant to protect special education students and other minority groups, when you have a federal government that is going after LGBTQ+ students, primarily our trans and non-binary students, when you have a federal government who is forcefully going after immigrant families, making them live in fear of being removed from this country, our work to protect students becomes partisan.

When you have conservative groups, such as Moms for Liberty, who support conservative school board candidates to run for office who run on banning LGBTQ+ books, rights for LGBTQ+ students, and teaching of subjects around diversity, equity, and inclusion, our work and our advocacy becomes partisan.

The School Committee got involved in partisan politics when we voted unanimously to adopt my resolution affirming our support for our LGBTQ+ students and declare “that the Pittsfield School Committee declares the Pittsfield Public Schools to be a safe space for all students, regardless of gender identity or sexual orientation, and a safe space for students to explore their gender identity and/or sexual orientation”, because one party has decided that stripping rights away from these students is their stance and what they will continue to push. We took a stand because we believe we have a duty to support and protect our students.

It’s not enough for us education leaders to bury our heads in the sand and say “we are staying out of partisan politics” when our student’s rights and their wellbeing are on the line. I hope that all candidates start to understand this, and voters understand it when they go to the polls next week. I also hope the new School Committee will understand this, and continue to support our students even if that means getting involved in partisan politics.

March 13th School Committee Recap: The Budget Presentation

I am splitting the recap from our March 13th Meeting into two parts, one just on the budget presentation and one on everything else during the meeting.

Budget Presentation

Superintendent Curtis and Assistant Superintendent for Business and Finance Behnke presented the administration’s FY25 budget proposal.

Continue reading “March 13th School Committee Recap: The Budget Presentation”

Upcoming School Committee Meeting March 13th, 2023

Click here to view the agenda for the regular meeting

Click here to view the packet information

The Pittsfield School Committee will have a meeting on Wednesday, March 13th at 6pm in City Hall Council Chambers (70 Allen St). The meeting will also be broadcasted on PCTV Channel 1302, PCTV’s Facebook page, and PCTV Select.

Any member of the public may wish to speak during our public comment period. Public comment is limited to 3 minutes per person and the public comment period is limited to 15 minutes unless the school committee votes to extend the public comment period. Anyone wishing to speak during the public comment period may be required to sign up before the meeting starts.

Continue reading “Upcoming School Committee Meeting March 13th, 2023”

February 28th School Committee Meeting Recaps

February 28th Regular Meeting Recap

Click here to view the agenda and packet information for this meeting

Click here to view the meeting recording

Restricting Virtual School Enrollment – Commonwealth Virtual Schools (CMVS) are virtual schools that serve the whole state and are approved by the Board of Elementary and Secondary Education.

Under Massachusetts State Law a school committee may “restrict enrollment of its students in commonwealth virtual schools if the total enrollment of its students in commonwealth virtual schools exceeds 1 per cent of the total enrollment in its district; provided, however, that no student enrolled in a commonwealth virtual school shall be compelled to withdraw as a result of that vote.”

The Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE) has determined based on student enrollment data reported to them on October 1st, 2023 that more than 1% of students from Pittsfield are enrolled in a CMVS. Under DESE Guidelines the School Committee must vote by March 1st if it is considering restricting student enrollment in the CMVS.

Based on this information, the School Committee voted to restrict enrollment in CMVS to 1% in a 6 – 1 vote (I opposed the motion).

Continue reading “February 28th School Committee Meeting Recaps”

School Committee Meeting Recap February 14th, 2024

Click here to view the agenda and packet information for this meeting
Click here to view the meeting recording

Acceptance of Donation for Taconic’s Auto Technology Program – Toyota Motors North America, Inc. is looking to donate the use of a 2023 Toyota GR86 with an estimated value of $25,723 for 5 years for Taconic’s Auto Technology Program. School Committee policy requires the committee to accept any donation of $5,000 or more to the Pittsfield Public Schools. The School Committee voted to accept the donation.

Report on Education Spending Outside of School Committee Budget and Governor’s Budget Update

Assistant Superintendent for Business and Finance Kristen Behnke gave the presentation. Here is the most important information:

Big takeaway: If Pittsfield was in group 11 we could possibly receive $1 million to $1.5 million more based on rough estimates. More information will come during our budget workshop on February 28th.

Discussion of Submittal of an SOI with the MSBA Regarding Crosby Elementary School and the Submittal’s Role in the Restructuring Planning – The district is looking at a potential new building project on the Crosby site as a part of its restructuring project. In order to get state funding for the project, the Superintendent must submit a Statement of Interest (SOI) to the Massachusetts School Building Authority (MSBA) by Friday, April 12th. The School Committee and the City Council must vote to authorize the Superintendent to submit the SOI.

Superintendent Curtis gave an overview of the work the School Building Needs Commission and the school restructuring consultant DRA (who were the architects for the Taconic High School building project) have done. Here are some highlights of the presentation:

The proposed Joint City Council and School Committee Workshop would also include a tour of the Crosby and Conte sites.

This is the district’s master plan spanning out to 2046. Click here to view a larger version.

When asked about PHS administration mentioned that it would cost approximately $120 million to renovate PHS. It would also be difficult to run two building projects at once.

Approval of Memorandums of Understanding with the United Educators of Pittsfield and the Pittsfield Pittsfield Federation of School Employees/AFT, Local 1315, Bus Drivers’ & Attendants’ Unit – These Memorandums were tabled until our next regular meeting.

Next School Committee Meetings

At the moment our next meeting will be our budget workshop on Wednesday, February 28th at 5:30pm at Reid Middle School. Due to the nature of the workshop format this meeting will not be recorded (though the first portion of the meeting which is a group presentation might be, more information to come).

Our next regular meeting that is scheduled is Wednesday, March 13th at 6pm at City Hall in City Council Chambers.

Newsletter

Want updates like this to be sent to your inbox every Monday? Then sign up for my weekly School Committee newsletter here!

Upcoming School Committee Meeting February 14th, 2024

Click here to view the agenda for the meeting

Click here to view the packet information

The Pittsfield School Committee will have a meeting on Wednesday, February 14th at 6pm in City Hall Council Chambers (70 Allen St). The meeting will also be broadcasted on PCTV Channel 1302, PCTV’s Facebook page, and PCTV Select.

Any member of the public may wish to speak during our public comment period. Public comment is limited to 3 minutes per person and the public comment period is limited to 15 minutes unless the school committee votes to extend the public comment period. Anyone wishing to speak during the public comment period may be required to sign up before the meeting starts.

Agenda Highlights

Acceptance of Donation for Taconic’s Auto Technology Program – Toyota Motors North America, Inc. is looking to donate a 2023 2023 Toyota GR86 with an estimated value of $25,723 for Taconic’s Auto Technology Program. School Committee policy requires the committee to accept any donation of $5,000 or more to the Pittsfield Public Schools.

Report on Education Spending Outside of School Committee Budget and
Governor’s Budget Update

Discussion of Submittal of an SOI with the MSBA Regarding Crosby Elementary
School and the Submittal’s Role in the Restructuring Planning
– The district is looking at a potential new building project on the Crosby site as a part of its restructuring project. In order to get state funding for the project, the Superintendent must submit a Statement of Interest (SOI) to the Massachusetts School Building Authority (MSBA) by Friday, April 12th. The School Committee and the City Council must vote to authorize the Superintendent to submit the SOI. More information will be discussed at the meeting.

Executive Session
– There will be an executive session to discuss negotiations with the United Educators of Pittsfield (teachers union), the Pittsfield Educational Administrator’s Association (educational administrators union), and the Pittsfield Federation of School Employees/AFT, Local 1315, Bus Drivers’ & Attendants’ Unit.

Approval of Memorandums of Understanding with the United Educators of Pittsfield and the Pittsfield Pittsfield Federation of School Employees/AFT, Local 1315, Bus Drivers’ & Attendants’ Unit – These Memorandums will be discussed in executive session and then the School Committee will vote on them in open session. The Memorandums of Understanding will be released after the executive session.

School Committee Meeting Recap January 24th, 2024 + Budget Updates

Meeting Recap

Click here to view the agenda and packet for this meeting

Click here to view a recording of the meeting

First Reading on New Curriculum Materials and Courses

School Committee policy require all changes to curriculum and adoption of new curriculums and courses to be approved by the School Committee, with the proposals being read (voted on) at two different meetings.

The following came up for a first reading and will be on the agenda again at our next regular meeting.

New Textbooks (All approved)

  • Environmental Science for the AP Course – For AP Environmental Science at PHS
  • Young Producers Group Complete Curriculum – For Music Production 1 and 2, Music Appreciation, Career Awareness for Young Producers

Pilot Programs (All approved)

  • UFLI (pronounced you-fly) Foundations at Morningside – New literacy curriculum developed by the University of Florida based on “science of reading” principles with the goal of improving literacy outcomes for students.
  • TeachTown’s Meta Play – Meta Play is a Pre-K curriculum “offers a systematic, play-based approach to fostering the development of imagination and play skills in young children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD), intellectual disabilities, developmental delays, and social and emotional disabilities.”

New Courses (All approved)

  • PHS
    • High School Playwriting & Directing
    • High School Musical Theatre Performance
  • Reid (these elective courses were developed to rearrange elective course offerings in response to teacher turnover)
    • STEM Lab
    • Personal Finance
    • Introduction to Digital Literacy

Approval of New Tutoring Program – Ignite Tutoring Program

Ignite! Reading is a “new approach to reading instruction that is built to teach non-readers to READ”, utilizing 15  minutes a day of 1:1 virtual tutoring. Tutoring is for qualifying first graders based on reading ability.

At the meeting it was reported that the program has been working and the kids are very happy about meeting with their tutor/”friend” each day!

The School Committee voted to approve the pilot program.

Approval of School Committee Representatives

Per School Committee policy at its meeting after its organizational meeting the School Committee shall appoint members to serve as representatives to various bodies and groups. The Chair made the following recommendations for appointments, which the School Committee approved:

  • Berkshire Legislative Delegation: Hon. Peter Marchetti
  • Berkshire Anthenaeum Board of Trustees: Diana Belair
  • School Building Needs Commission: William Cameron
  • Berkshire Compact for Higher Education: TBD (the Chair does not know if this organization exits anymore)
  • Berkshire Chamber of Commerce: Sara Hathaway
  • City Council: William Cameron and Sara Hathaway
  • School Councils: Daniel Elias
  • Berkshire Educational Resources K-12: William Cameron

Presentation on Paraprofessional Educational Opportunities

Due to a communication issue, this item was tabled until the next meeting.

Budget Updates

Governor Healey released her proposed state budget for Fiscal Year 2025 (which runs from July 1st, 2024 to June 30th, 2025). After the release of the Governor’s budget, the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE’s) released it’s preliminary estimates of Chapter 70 school aid (which is where Pittsfield Public Schools gets most of its funding from).

Based on DESE’s estimates, Pittsfield is estimated to receive $61,496,778 in Chapter 70 aid this fiscal year. This is a $649,248 increase compared to last physical year.

For comparison here are the increases in Chapter 70 aid spanning back to FY18:

  • FY18: $390,423
  • FY19: $2,119,739
  • FY20 $5,020,681
  • FY21: $477,007
  • FY22: $1,497,516
  • FY23: $4,594,226
  • FY24: $6,592,719

For a state education funding’s expert on this, I would highly recommend checking out Tracy Novick’s Whos of Who-cester Blog Post Governor Healey FY25 budget recommendation. But here is the highlight of the post:

If you’re in a district with falling enrollment and not a high rate of low income students (thus meaning you’re not getting the driving push of the SOA increases in low income rates), a 1.35% inflation rate isn’t going to be enough to push a significant increase. It’s certainly made it harder for districts still in hold harmless to get back out, particularly on top of the $60 per pupil minimums last year. 

Even the Gateways–and yes, I’m including Worcester in this–aren’t seeing the same increases we have in past years, when the inflation rate was being driven by the pandemic spending of previous quarters.  

And no one’s budget is increasing by 1.35%. 

More to come on the FY25 budget process at our next School Committee meeting in February.

Upcoming Subcommittee Meetings

  • January 29th @ 5:30pm Personnel and Negotiations Subcommittee Meeting at Herberg Middle School – Executive session to conduct collective bargaining sessions with the United Educators of Pittsfield (Teachers Union). (Agenda)
  • January 30th @ 5:30pm Personnel and Negotiations Subcommittee Meeting at Mercer – Executive session to conduct collective bargaining sessions with the Pittsfield Educational Administrators’ Association (PEAA) (Agenda)

Upcoming Dates

  • January 22-February 2, 2024 – Annual Family Survey Range
  • February 2, 2024 – Secondary Families Receive Notice of Quarter 2 report cards
  • February 2, 2024 5-7p.m. For the LOVE OF ART Exhibit Opens @ the Lichtenstein!
  • February 2 – February 9th – One Week to Celebrate our LOVE OF ART!! Join to view midway Senior Portfolios, Drawings & Paintings, Photography, and Ceramics works by Pittsfield High School artists!
    • Empty Bowls Project: A handmade bowl. A simple meal. A way to fight hunger. Help us fill the bowls in our community! Join us for our Empty Bowls Event. All the proceeds raised during this event go to the St Joseph’s/ Christian Center Food Pantry in Pittsfield. Dinner of soup and bread “to go” will be available with a suggested donation for the one-of-a-kind ceramic bowls that are taken home after.
  • February 14th, 2024 – Next regular School Committee meeting

In Defense of Students on IEPs

I attended the United Educators of Pittsfield’s Mayoral Q&A session on October 19th. I decided to attend to learn about the mayoral candidates’ positions on educational matters as if elected I will be serving with one of them on the Pittsfield School Committee.

During his opening statement mayoral candidate John Krol made the following remarks that I feel is worth sharing:

“There’s three different types of students in every single classroom, there are high performers, there are middle of the road, and then there are those who are on IEPs and those kids that also can be disruptions in our classrooms.”

As a former student who was on an IEP throughout most of my time in the Pittsfield Public Schools, I find this remark highly offensive not only to me but to our students on IEPs in our district.

Continue reading “In Defense of Students on IEPs”